Liability & construction
A building is most dangerous while it’s going up
A run of building collapses in Delhi this week, including one of a structure still under construction, is a hard reminder that a building is at its most fragile while it is being built. That phase exposes three parties at once, and the responsibility for it sits with the people putting it up.
A half-built structure is a building holding its breath: props and scaffolding, concrete not yet set, loads not yet settled. For a while, it is the most fragile version of itself.
This week has brought a painful run of building collapses in Delhi, among them a structure that came down while still under construction, with reports that work had continued despite restrictions. The lives lost are what matter most, and the first duty these events raise is simply to build safely. But they also point at a risk that is easy to overlook, because we think of a building as a finished, solid thing. It is at its most dangerous long before that, while it is going up, and the responsibility for that phase, and for the people it puts at risk, sits squarely with those carrying out the work.
For any developer, contractor or owner undertaking construction, it is worth being clear about who is exposed during that phase, and what answers for each of them.
In short
- A building under construction is more fragile, not less, than a finished one, and it puts three parties at risk at once.
- The works themselves are covered by Contractors’ All Risk, a project policy for the construction phase.
- The workers on site sit under workmen’s compensation and personal accident; the public and neighbours under public liability.
- And cutting corners, or building unlawfully, adds a criminal liability no policy can carry. Cover is never a substitute for building safely.
Put simply: a construction project needs cover for three different exposures. Contractors’ All Risk cover answers for damage to the works during construction; workmen’s compensation for the workers on site; and public liability for harm to people and property outside the project. Each is a different policy doing a different job.
The riskiest phase of a building’s life
A finished, well-built structure is designed to stand safely for decades. A building mid-construction is a different thing entirely: incomplete load paths, temporary supports doing permanent work, excavations, heavy materials moving overhead, and a site full of people. That is why the construction phase carries its own, higher risk of collapse and injury, and why it has its own family of insurance built around it, separate from the cover on a completed building. Treating a project as if it were already the safe, finished thing it will one day be is the mistake underneath a lot of construction loss.
Three parties are exposed at once
What makes construction distinctive is that a single failure reaches three different groups together. There is the project itself, the works, the materials, the equipment on site, answered by Contractors’ All Risk cover. There are the workers, who are among the most exposed people on any site, answered by workmen’s compensation and personal accident. And there is everyone outside the hoarding, the neighbours, the passers-by, the adjoining property, answered by public liability. A serious collapse can trigger all three at once, which is exactly why they need to be arranged together and deliberately, not left to chance.
Cutting corners doesn’t just risk the building
There is a harder point that events like this week’s force into the open. When a collapse follows construction that was unsafe, unauthorised, or continued in defiance of a restriction, the consequences are not only financial. The people responsible can face criminal liability, as a personal legal matter, and that exposure cannot be transferred to any insurer. A policy can pay to rebuild the works and meet a civil claim; it cannot undo a decision to cut a corner, and it will not stand in for an accused. The only protection against that is to build safely and lawfully in the first place, which is, in the end, the point of all of it.
What responds, and what doesn’t
Held together, the picture is clear enough. The insurable losses, damage to the works, injury to workers, and civil claims from the public, are answered by Contractors’ All Risk, workmen’s compensation and public liability respectively, within their wordings and conditions. The uninsurable part, the criminal responsibility for unsafe or unlawful work, is answered only by doing the work properly. Cover is the financial backstop for the honest accident; it is not, and was never meant to be, a shield for a cut corner.
How a construction-phase failure maps to cover
It helps to separate who is harmed, because the works, the workers and the public are answered by different covers, and one consequence is answered by none. This is category-level — it describes how cover generally works, not any one insurer’s product.
| The loss | The cover that typically responds |
|---|---|
| Damage to or collapse of the works during construction | Contractors’ All Risk (project cover) |
| A worker injured or killed on site | Workmen’s Compensation and Group Personal Accident |
| Injury to the public or neighbours, or damage to their property | Public / commercial general liability |
| Criminal liability for unsafe or unauthorised construction | Not insurable — safe, lawful building only |
A five-minute check for a construction project
You don’t need a full review to find the biggest gaps. Five questions usually surface them:
- Is the project itself insured during construction?Contractors’ All Risk covers the works while they are being built, which an ordinary property policy does not.
- Are the workers on site covered?Workmen’s compensation and personal accident for the people most exposed on any site.
- Do you have public liability for those outside the hoarding?Neighbours and passers-by are third parties you owe a duty of care, and a collapse can reach them.
- Are you building lawfully, with permits and within restrictions?Beyond safety, this is where criminal exposure, which no cover carries, is created or avoided.
- If the works failed tomorrow, who is liable and who is covered?Knowing that in advance is the difference between a managed loss and a catastrophe.
Frequently asked questions
What is Contractors' All Risk insurance?
It is a project policy for the construction phase, covering physical loss or damage to the works, materials and equipment on site while a building is being built, and often third-party liability arising from the works, subject to the wording. It is separate from the cover on a completed building.
Are workers on a construction site covered?
Construction workers are covered against injury or death on the job under workmen's compensation, the employer's statutory liability, alongside personal accident cover. Construction also carries its own worker-welfare obligations, so the position should be confirmed for your project.
Who is liable if a building under construction harms the public?
Depending on the facts, the developer, owner or contractor can be held liable for harm to third parties caused by the works. Public liability cover responds to those civil claims, subject to its limits and conditions. It does not, however, cover criminal liability.
Does insurance cover illegal or unsafe construction?
No. Beyond the property and civil-liability exposures, unsafe or unauthorised construction can bring criminal liability on those responsible, and that cannot be insured. The only protection is to build safely and lawfully; cover is a backstop for an honest accident, not for a cut corner.
Can a broker help a construction project?
A broker's duty under IRDAI regulation is to you, the client, not the insurer, so a broker can help put the project, worker and liability covers in place together, and, if a loss occurs, fight a complex claim on your behalf. That describes the effort put in, not a guaranteed outcome.
What happens when you talk to us
A 20-minute video call with a Growth Advisor — no obligation, and no quote pushed. It opens with a five-minute video from our founder on how the benefits stack works and why Ethika exists; the rest is your questions. You’ll leave with an honest read on your current cover and claims experience, and a straight answer on whether we can genuinely help — even if you never become a client.
20 minutes with a Growth Advisor. No obligation.
A note on this page. Everything here is general information, not insurance, legal, financial or tax advice, and nothing is an offer. What project, worker and liability cover respond to depends on your own policy wording; criminal liability for unsafe or unauthorised construction is a personal legal matter on which you should take qualified legal advice. For advice about your cover, talk to us. The Delhi incidents are referenced from reporting dated 17 November 2026.